Mike Pelfrey made his last start of the year today and looked simply terrible. He gave up 5 runs on 9 hits over 3 innings of work. That is not going to be good enough any day of the week. However, the pitching market is low for this offseason so the final question is if the Mets should non tender the pitcher.
The Mets have the following starters not counting Pelfrey:
Johan Santana: He is coming back from injury and not pitching an inning in the majors in 2011. Hopefully he can give the Mets some innings for next year.
Chris Capuano: The Mets love Capuano and it seems like Capuano wants to return to the Mets, I think this deal can get done.
Dillon Gee: He has shown flashes of brilliance in his rookie year so hopefully he can continue that for 2011.
Jon Niese: He has shown ace potential at points this season, the only problem is that he is yet to pitch a full good season in the major leagues.
R.A. Dickey: Simply a great pitcher who will give us innings and quality games.
So the Mets have 5 quality pitchers for their rotation in 2012 without Mike Pelfrey and that is discounting Matt Harvey, who will most likely make his major league debut next year. So why would we pay this crap pitcher 6MM dollars when we don’t even need this guy? We shouldn’t pay Pelfrey because he has no way of being succesful. The man has no out pitch just his fastball that he seems to throw 90% of the time with an ok slider, split, and curveball that he throws twice a game. Mike Pelfrey should have no place on this team next year and honestly, I am sick of him. The only good thing about him is that he throws a lot of pitches. The bad greatly outplays the good.